Insights

Do you control your business, or just watch it?

Companies have never had better reports. And yet more and more owners feel that the business is running them, and no report on their desk explains why.

The question I am almost never asked

For a decade the same phone call has been finding me across Europe, always carrying a version of the same worried question: are our numbers correct, can we trust this report, and why do sales and finance bring two different figures for the same month? In all those years I can count on the fingers of one hand the times someone asked me the opposite question, the one about what is missing from the numbers, about what happened in the business that no report ever recorded.

I have written five articles in this space and, looking back, every one of them served that first question, because all five were about the number you already have: how to agree on it, how to explain it, how to trust it, what getting to it costs, and what must be written underneath it.

This article is about what none of them touched, because once the numbers are finally correct a harder question appears. Do your reports let you control the business, or only watch it?

The most expensive things are not in any report

A report is a record, and it records what happened: the revenue you booked, the margin you kept, the costs you carried, the claims you paid. When it is built well it records all of this accurately, and the second of my five articles already conceded where that ends: the numbers answer only the question “what happened?”.

What I did not say then is what that concession costs. The most expensive things in a business are frequently not events at all, because the client you are losing rarely announces the decision and the opportunity you are missing leaves no trace behind it. Nothing has happened yet, so nothing was recorded, and a record can only contain what was recorded. Every company produces a report of what happened, and nobody produces a report of what did not, even though that is where the year’s largest losses are written. This blindness is the nature of reporting itself, whatever tool it runs on, and in every industry it wears a different costume.

In retail the costume is at least easy to picture: the customer who reached for an empty shelf and drove to the discounter across the road is a sale no report will ever contain. In a bank and an insurance company the loss is quieter, and those are the rooms worth walking through slowly.

Banks and insurers: the departure that is already underway

Banks and insurance companies do not need lessons in reporting, because reporting on risk and on the regulator’s questions is probably the most disciplined reporting in the entire economy, and when such a report says the margin fell, the margin fell. But it is worth asking who all that discipline was built for. In a regulated financial institution analytics grew up as a product for the regulator, so the reports the supervisor requires must be perfect and always come first, the reports finance requires come right behind them, and by the time the discipline reaches the people whose job is the client’s next decision, it has thinned into a summary of what was sold last month.

The regulator is a customer every bank and insurer must serve, but the regulator cannot be the one who drives their analytics. Everything a supervisor asks about looks backward, and the people at the end of that priority list, the ones facing the client, are the only ones in the building who are paid to change what happens next rather than to explain what already did.

The cost of that ordering lives in the quarter before the account is closed. A profitable client almost never leaves a bank on the day of leaving: first the salary starts arriving into an account at another bank, then the card is used less, then the savings quietly migrate, and by the time the relationship formally ends the client made the real decision months earlier. Every signal of that decision was sitting in the bank’s own data the whole time, where nobody thought to look. This spring an American study of retail banking put a number on the pattern I have been describing to bankers for years: one in five clients had moved money away from their main bank in just the previous three months, and the researchers gave the behavior a name, soft switching. The report sees only the closed account, never the leaving.

In insurance the same departure arrives one policy at a time. Consider a client who has insured the car, the apartment and the family’s health with your company for years, and who this month quietly lets the car policy expire. In the book that is one small lapse among thousands, the totals barely move, and new sales elsewhere cover the difference within the week. But his health policy comes up for renewal in a few months, and the honest question is what the odds are that he will renew it as if nothing had happened. That lapse was the first renewal date to arrive after the client had already changed his mind about you, which makes the renewal dates of his remaining policies a countdown that no standard report is watching, even though one phone call in those few months could still change the outcome.

The mirror image is the sale. The report counts every policy you sold, but nowhere in it is the policy nobody ever offered, to the client who insures the apartment with you and the car with someone else and was never asked why. The research put numbers on that gap years ago: clients who hold only a car policy leave their insurer at a rate of roughly one in six each year, while those who hold their home and car with the same company leave at roughly one in twenty, and the policy that was never offered is a departure already scheduled.

In insurance the opportunity has a deadline, and the standard report arrives only after it has closed.

The test you can run on Monday

If you want to know honestly whether your own reporting can answer the real questions, there is a test that costs nothing: ask how much of the actual analysis in your company happens in a spreadsheet, exported from the expensive system you bought precisely so that nobody would have to work in spreadsheets anymore.

The export is your best people telling you something important: the standard report did not hold the answer, so they pulled the data out to ask the question themselves. The spreadsheet is good because in it a person can finally ask anything, and it is a warning because that freedom is manual, slow, invisible to everyone else, and lives in one file on one laptop that leaves when that person leaves. Every export is a question your system could not answer, and if you count the exports you have counted the distance between the reporting you have and the control you believe you have.

Controlling means arriving before it happens

None of this means throwing out your reports: the trustworthy number I have spent five articles defending is the entry ticket, not the destination. A report can only show you what already happened. Your largest costs this year are the things that did not. The client before the account closed, the renewal before it quietly expired, the sale before the shelf emptied: controlling the business means reaching those moments while they can still be changed, and that requires a foundation underneath the reports you already trust, one that can take the unusual question tomorrow morning, on the data you already own, and answer it as reliably as it answers the standard one.

Most of the reports that land on your desk are accurate, which is exactly why the real question is the difference between running the business and being run by it, and it deserves to be asked of every report that arrives this week. Does it help you control the business, or only watch it?

Value Discovery

Bring the decision that is late.

A free Value Discovery, sixty to ninety minutes, built around your industry and your Monday morning.